I Tried 5 Healthiest McDonald’s Orders—These 2 Were Surprisingly Tasty

Fast food is often synonymous with indulgence and high calories, but sometimes, especially on hectic days, it offers a quick, convenient solution. With over 13,000 locations across the U.S., McDonald’s is a top choice for many.

Known for its affordable, tasty meals, the challenge arises when trying to find healthier options. But, are there McDonald’s meals that are not only nutritious but also satisfying? I put five healthier McDonald’s orders to the test to find out if they truly deliver on both taste and nutrition.

In this article, I’ll share my experience trying some of the healthiest McDonald’s options recommended by dietitians. After tasting each one, I’ll break down the nutrition facts and explain which options are worth ordering again and which ones fell flat.

Healthier McDonald’s Orders: Are They Worth It?

To get an idea of what constitutes a “healthier” option, I consulted dietitians to pick five McDonald’s meals that offer lower calories, healthier ingredients, and a better balance of nutrients.

But the big question remains: do they taste good enough to justify swapping out your usual go-to burger or sandwich? Here’s how each of the items stacked up.

1. Egg McMuffin: A Lower-Calorie Breakfast Staple

Nutrition (Per order):

Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
310	13g	6g	770mg	30g	2g	3g	17g

Why It’s Healthy:

The Egg McMuffin is a great choice for a lower-calorie breakfast that provides a good mix of protein, fats, and carbs. With only 310 calories and 17 grams of protein, it’s a solid option to start your day. It also delivers essential nutrients like choline and vitamin B12 from the egg.

Taste Test:

I found the Egg McMuffin to be a flavorful and satisfying breakfast option, especially when enhanced with a bit of hot sauce.

The combination of the bacon (which I kept for extra protein) and the soft, toasted English muffin was delightful. I particularly appreciated the savory flavor of the American cheese, which added richness to the sandwich.

While I typically prefer breakfasts with more protein, this was a great grab-and-go option for busy mornings.

Dietitian Insight:

According to dietitians, the Egg McMuffin is a balanced breakfast that can keep hunger at bay. With a reasonable amount of protein, carbs, and fats, it offers a quick, satisfying meal without going overboard on calories.

2. Deluxe McCrispy (Without Mayo): High Protein, Low Calories

Nutrition (Per order, without mayo):

Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
430	15g	2.5g	980mg	48g	2g	10g	27g

Why It’s Healthy:

The Deluxe McCrispy Chicken Sandwich is packed with 27 grams of protein, making it one of the more protein-rich options at McDonald’s. Skipping the mayo significantly reduces the fat content while keeping the calorie count reasonable at 430 calories.

Taste Test:

I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this sandwich. The chicken fillet was a whole piece of white meat, unlike the McChicken patty, which tends to be processed.

The sandwich was hearty, and the texture of the chicken was superior to what you’d typically expect from fast food. Without the mayo, it was a bit dry, but pairing it with a lower-calorie sauce like the spicy buffalo or tangy barbecue added just the right touch.

Overall, it’s a solid, protein-packed option when you’re craving fast food.

Dietitian Insight:

Dietitians suggest the Deluxe McCrispy without mayo for its balance of protein and calories. While the fried chicken and butter do add some fat, it remains a convenient high-protein choice for those needing a quick meal.

3. McDonald’s Fruit and Maple Oatmeal: Fiber-Packed But Lacks Flavor

Nutrition (Per order):

Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
320	4.5g	1.5g	150mg	64g	5g	31g	6g

Why It’s Healthy:

This oatmeal is one of the few low-fat, high-fiber breakfast items available at McDonald’s. The real fruit toppings add natural sweetness and fiber, making it a good option for those looking to boost their fiber intake.

Taste Test:

While the oatmeal wasn’t bad, it was far from memorable. The diced apples and cranberries added a nice texture and sweetness, but the oatmeal itself tasted bland.

At 6 grams of protein, it didn’t feel like a substantial meal to me. Although it’s higher in fiber, which is great for digestion and satiety, I personally prefer a breakfast with a higher protein content to keep me fuller longer.

Dietitian Insight:

The Fruit and Maple Oatmeal is a healthier choice because it provides a mix of complex carbs, fiber, and real fruit. However, if you’re looking for something more filling and protein-packed, this may not be the best option.

4. 6-Piece Chicken Nuggets: A Low-Calorie Snack Option

Nutrition (Per order):

Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
250	15g	2.5g	500mg	15g	0g	0g	14g

Why It’s Healthy:

With only 250 calories and 14 grams of protein, a 6-piece Chicken McNuggets order is a lighter option compared to larger fast food meals. It’s a decent way to indulge in fast food while keeping calorie and fat intake in check.

Taste Test:

The nostalgia of McDonald’s Chicken McNuggets didn’t live up to my expectations. The flavor lacked the chicken taste I was hoping for, and the texture was a bit too chewy for my liking.

The biggest disappointment was that McDonald’s forgot to include the buffalo dipping sauce I ordered, which would have likely enhanced the overall experience.

Despite its lower calorie count and decent protein content, I wouldn’t choose these nuggets over other fast food options in the future.

Dietitian Insight:

Dietitians highlight the nuggets as a good snack option when paired with a lighter side. They can satisfy cravings without overwhelming your daily calorie intake, especially if you’re mindful of portion control.

5. Classic Hamburger: A Simple, Lighter Burger

Nutrition (Per order):

Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
250	9g	3.5g	510mg	30g	1g	5g	12g

Why It’s Healthy:

The Classic Hamburger is one of McDonald’s lowest-calorie burger options, containing just 250 calories and 12 grams of protein. It’s free from trans fats, and its simplicity makes it a lighter choice compared to larger burgers like the Quarter Pounder.

Taste Test:

Surprisingly, I enjoyed the simplicity of McDonald’s Classic Hamburger. The combination of ketchup, pickles, and onions added just the right amount of flavor, and the patty itself was decently seasoned.

However, at only 250 calories, it felt more like a snack than a meal. The lack of healthy side options, such as fries or apple slices, made it hard to find a fulfilling meal combination.

Still, if you’re looking for a small, lighter burger option, the Classic Hamburger is a decent choice.

Dietitian Insight:

Dietitians recommend the Classic Hamburger for those who want a lower-calorie burger option. Its simple ingredients and lower calorie count make it a better choice compared to McDonald’s larger, more calorie-dense burgers.

Nutritional Comparison Table

Menu Item	Calories	Fat	Saturated Fat	Sodium	Carbs	Fiber	Sugar	Protein
Egg McMuffin	310	13g	6g	770mg	30g	2g	3g	17g
Deluxe McCrispy (No Mayo)	430	15g	2.5g	980mg	48g	2g	10g	27g
Fruit and Maple Oatmeal	320	4.5g	1.5g	150mg	64g	5g	31g	6g
6-Piece Chicken Nuggets	250	15g	2.5g	500mg	15g	0g	0g	14g
Classic Hamburger	250	9g	3.5g	510mg	30g	1g	5g	12g

Conclusion:

In my taste-test of the five healthiest McDonald’s items, I found two standouts: the Egg McMuffin and the Deluxe McCrispy (without mayo). Both offered a balance of taste and nutrition, making them go-to options for those seeking a quick yet healthier meal at McDonald’s.

While the Fruit and Maple Oatmeal and 6-Piece Chicken Nuggets were decent, they didn’t impress enough to warrant a reorder. The Classic Hamburger is a simple and light burger option, ideal for those seeking a lower-calorie meal, though it may leave you wanting more in terms of fullness.

FAQs